3D Printing Resin vs Filament: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide

When it comes to 3D printing, choosing the right material is crucial for achieving the desired results. Two popular options that often leave users pondering are resin and filament. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the differences between 3D printing resin and filament, helping you make an informed decision for your projects.

Before we dive into the specifics, it’s important to understand the basics. 3D printing resin is a liquid photopolymer that solidifies when exposed to specific wavelengths of light. On the other hand, 3D printing filament is a solid thermoplastic material that is melted and extruded through a nozzle to create the desired object layer by layer. Now, let’s explore the key aspects of each material to help you understand their unique characteristics and applications.

Material Composition

Understanding the composition of 3D printing resin and filament is essential to grasp their distinct qualities and properties. 3D printing resin primarily consists of a liquid photopolymer, which is a combination of monomers, oligomers, and photoinitiators. These components work together to create a material that solidifies when exposed to specific wavelengths of light. On the other hand, 3D printing filament is typically made from thermoplastic materials such as polylactic acid (PLA), acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), or polyethylene terephthalate glycol (PETG). Each type of filament has its unique characteristics, such as temperature resistance, flexibility, or strength, making it suitable for different applications.

Types of Resins

There are various types of resins available for 3D printing, each catering to different needs and preferences. Standard resins are commonly used for general-purpose printing and offer a balance between cost and print quality. They provide decent resolution and are suitable for a wide range of applications. Engineering resins, on the other hand, are specifically formulated to meet the demands of functional prototypes, with enhanced mechanical properties and durability. They are often used in industries such as automotive, aerospace, and healthcare. Additionally, specialty resins, such as flexible, transparent, or castable resins, cater to specific requirements where unique properties are necessary.

Types of Filaments

The world of 3D printing filament offers a wide array of options, each with its own set of characteristics and applications. PLA filament, derived from renewable resources like cornstarch or sugarcane, is one of the most popular choices for beginners. It is easy to print with and offers good print quality, making it suitable for a range of non-functional objects. ABS filament, known for its durability and temperature resistance, is commonly used for functional prototypes and parts that require higher strength. PETG filament combines the ease of printing with the strength of ABS, making it a versatile option for various applications. Other filaments, such as nylon, flexible materials, and composite filaments infused with additives like carbon fiber or wood, offer additional possibilities for specialized projects.

Print Quality and Resolution

Print quality and resolution are key factors to consider when comparing 3D printing resin and filament. Resin-based printers generally offer higher resolution due to the liquid nature of the material and the ability to produce finer details. The photopolymerization process allows for intricate designs with smooth surfaces and sharp edges. Filament-based printers, while not achieving the same level of resolution as resin, can still produce excellent prints. The layer-by-layer deposition method can result in visible lines or ridges, but with proper settings and post-processing techniques, the quality can be significantly improved. Additionally, filament-based printers often provide a wider range of color options, allowing for more vibrant and visually appealing prints.

Layer Adhesion

The layer adhesion of 3D prints is an important aspect to consider, as it directly affects the strength and durability of the final object. Resin prints generally have excellent layer adhesion due to the liquid nature of the material and the curing process, resulting in strong and solid parts. However, resin prints may be prone to brittle behavior if not properly cured or exposed to insufficient light. Filament prints, on the other hand, rely on the bonding strength between layers to create a solid object. Factors such as print temperature, print speed, and infill density can influence layer adhesion. Proper calibration and optimization of these settings can result in strong prints with good layer adhesion.

Print Quality Factors

Several factors can affect the print quality of both resin and filament prints. For resin prints, factors such as exposure time, layer thickness, and resin viscosity can impact the final outcome. Finding the right balance between these parameters is crucial to achieve optimal print quality. Filament prints, on the other hand, are influenced by factors such as print speed, cooling settings, and filament diameter consistency. Proper calibration of these settings can help minimize issues like stringing, warping, or layer shifting, ultimately improving the print quality.

Strength and Durability

Strength and durability are crucial considerations, especially when printing functional or load-bearing objects. Resin and filament prints have different characteristics in terms of strength and durability, making them suitable for different applications.

Resin Print Strength

Resin prints typically exhibit higher strength and rigidity compared to filament prints due to the nature of the material and the curing process. The photopolymerization of resin allows for the creation of solid and homogenous parts, resulting in good structural integrity. However, it is important to note that the brittleness of certain resin types may make them less suitable for applications requiring high impact resistance or flexibility.

Filament Print Strength

Filament prints can also achieve good strength and durability, depending on the material used and the printing settings. Filaments like ABS and PETG offer higher impact resistance and toughness, making them suitable for functional prototypes or parts that undergo mechanical stress. Additionally, composite filaments infused with additives like carbon fiber or glass fiber can significantly enhance the strength and stiffness of printed objects, making them suitable for demanding applications.

Post-Processing and Finishing

Post-processing and finishing techniques are essential for enhancing the appearance and functionality of 3D printed objects. Both resin and filament prints require different approaches to achieve the desired results.

Resin Print Finishing

Resin prints generally require post-processing steps to remove excess resin and achieve a smooth surface finish. After printing, the object is typically washed in a solvent to remove any uncured resin. Depending on the desired finish, additional steps such as sanding, polishing, or painting may be necessary. Resin prints can also be cured further using UV light or heat to improve their mechanical properties. However, it is important to handle resin prints with care during post-processing, as they may still be delicate until fully cured.

Filament Print Finishing

Filament prints can also benefit from post-processing techniques to achieve a higher-quality finish. Sanding, filling, and priming are commonly used to smooth out the visible layer lines and imperfections on the surface. Depending on the desired outcome, additional techniques such as vapor smoothing, acetone polishing for ABS prints, or using specialized coatings can be employed. Filament prints also lend themselves well to painting and other decorative finishes due to the wide range of color options available.

Print Speed and Efficiency

Print speed and efficiency are crucial considerations, especially for time-sensitive projects or large-scale production. Resin and filament prints differ in terms of their printing speed and overall productivity.

Resin Print Speed

Resin-based printers generally offer faster print speeds compared to filament-based printers. This is because the entire layer can be exposed to light simultaneously, allowing for quicker curing times. However, it is important to note that the print speed can vary depending on factors such as the layer height, exposure settings, and the complexity of the design. Printing larger objects or objects with intricate details may still require longer print times to ensure proper curing and avoid potential curing issues.

Filament Print Speed

Filament-based printers typically have slower print speeds compared to resin printers. This is because the nozzle needs to move across the build area, depositing the melted filament layer by layer. The print speed can vary depending on factors such as the layer height, print temperature, and the complexity of the design. However, filament printers offer the advantage of being able to print larger objects without significantly impacting the print time compared to resin printers.

Material Efficiency

Material efficiency is another aspect to consider when it comes to print speed and overall productivity. Resin-based printers generally have higher material utilization due to the nature of the photopolymerization process. The liquid resin is selectively cured, minimizing material waste. On the other hand, filament-based printers can have higher material waste, especially if support structures are required. However, with proper design optimization and support structure generation, material waste can be minimized for both resin and filament prints.

Cost Analysis

Cost is a significant factor to consider when choosing between 3D printing resin and filament. Several aspects contribute to the overall cost, including material price, wastage, and equipment requirements.

Resin Print Costs

Resin prints generally have higher material costs compared to filament prints. Photopolymer resins can be more expensive per volume compared to filament spools. Additionally, resin prints may require additional consumables such as cleaning solvents and post-processing materials, which can add to the overall cost. It is also worth noting that resin-based printers tend to have a higher initial investment cost compared to filament-based printers.

Filament Print Costs

Filament prints generally have lower material costs compared to resin prints. Filament spools are available at a wide range of price points, depending on the type and brand of filament. PLA filament, for example, is often more affordable compared to specialty filaments like carbon fiber or metal-infused filaments. Additionally, filament printers have a lower initial investment cost, making them more accessible for beginners or those on a tight budget. However, it is important to consider the overall cost of filament prints, including the potential wastage from failed prints or support structures, as well as the energy consumption of the printer itself.

Safety Considerations

Ensuring safety during the 3D printing process is of utmost importance. Both resin and filament printing have specific safety considerations that need to be taken into account.

Resin Printing Safety

Resin printing involves handling liquid photopolymers and exposure to UV light during the curing process. It is essential to wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), such as gloves and safety glasses, to protect the skin and eyes from direct contact with the resin. Proper ventilation is also important to minimize the inhalation of potentially harmful fumes emitted during the printing and curing process. Additionally, proper disposal of resin waste and cleaning solvents is necessary to prevent environmental contamination.

Filament Printing Safety

Filament printing generally involves working with solid thermoplastic materials, which have different safety considerations. While the filaments themselves are typically safe to handle, certain materials like ABS can release potentially harmful fumes when heated above their melting point. It is advisable to operate filament printers in well-ventilated areas or use air filtration systems to minimize the inhalation of these fumes. Additionally, the heated printer bed and nozzle can cause burns if not handled with caution. Proper training and adherence to safety guidelines are essential to prevent accidents and injuries.

Environmental Impact

As sustainability gains importance in various industries, understanding the environmental impact of different materials is essential. Both resin and filament printing have distinct environmental considerations.

Resin Printing Environmental Impact

Resin printing has some environmental challenges due to the use of photopolymer resins, which are not biodegradable. Improper disposal of uncured resin or resin waste can lead to environmental pollution and harm ecosystems. It is crucial to follow proper disposal guidelines and recycle or treat the waste materials responsibly. However, advancements in resin technology have led to the development of more eco-friendly options, such as bio-based resins or resins with reduced toxicity, which can help mitigate the environmental impact.

Filament Printing Environmental Impact

Filament printing offers some advantages in terms of environmental impact. Many filament materials, such as PLA, are derived from renewable resources and are biodegradable under the right conditions. This means that filament prints have the potential to be more environmentally friendly and can be composted or recycled. Additionally, the filament printing process generally consumes less energy compared to resin printing, further reducing its environmental footprint. However, it is important to note that some specialty filaments, such as those infused with additives or metals, may have a higher environmental impact due to the extraction and manufacturing processes involved.

Application Suitability

The choice between resin and filament printing depends on the specific requirements and applications of your project. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each material can help determine the most suitable choice.

Resin Printing Applications

Resin printing is well-suited for applications that require high levels of detail and surface finish, such as jewelry, dental models, or intricate prototypes. The ability to produce fine features and smooth surfaces makes resin prints ideal for objects that demand aesthetic appeal. Resin prints are also suitable for functional parts that require rigidity and dimensional accuracy. However, it is important to consider the limitations of resin prints in terms of impact resistance and flexibility, which may make them less suitable for certain functional applications.

Filament Printing Applications

Filament printing offers versatility and a wide range of material options, making it suitable for a diverse set of applications. PLA filament, for example, is commonly used for non-functional objects like figurines, decorations, or architectural models. ABS filament is well-suited for functional prototypes, enclosures, or mechanical parts that require higher strength and durability. PETG filament combines the ease of printing with good mechanical properties, making it suitable for a variety of applications. Specialty filaments like flexible materials, nylon, or composite filaments offer unique properties for specific projects, such as wearable devices, robotics, or engineering components.

Future Trends and Developments

The world of 3D printing is constantly evolving, with new technologies and materials emerging. Staying informed about the latest trends and developments can provide insights into the advancements that lie ahead.

Resin Printing Trends

Resin printing is experiencing significant advancements in terms of material options and printer capabilities. Manufacturers are constantly developing new resins with improved mechanical properties, impact resistance, and flexibility. These advancements expand the range of applications for resin printing, making it more suitable for functional parts in various industries. Additionally, the development of faster curing resins and improved printing techniques can further enhance the efficiency and productivity of resin-based printers.

Filament Printing Trends

Filament printing is also evolving, with manufacturers continuously introducing new materials and filament types. The market now offers a wide range of filaments infused with additives like carbon fiber, metal particles, or wood, allowing for enhanced strength, conductivity, or aesthetic properties. The development of soluble support materials for complex prints is also a growing trend, simplifying the post-processing and reducing the manual effort required to remove support structures. Furthermore, advancements in filament extrusion technology and wireless connectivity are making filament printers more user-friendly and accessible to a wider audience.

By understanding the differences in material composition, print quality, strength, post-processing options, cost, safety considerations, environmental impact, and application suitability, you can make an informed decision about choosing between 3D printing resin and filament. Both materials offer unique advantages and limitations, catering to different needs and preferences. Stay updated with the latest trends and developments in the field to ensure you are utilizing the best material for your 3D printing endeavors.

Related video of 3D Printing Resin vs Filament: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide